My heart goes out to Bryan, who posted comments on an earlier post. He's frustrated that there's no cure for OA. He's right that currently available treatment options are incomplete and only palliative, not a true solution to the problem.
Please understand that scientific principles exist, even if we don't like them. Cartilage tissue is very complicated. Research hasn't yet revealed why the deterioration is OA is so unpredictable (one hip is shot, the other is fine; knees are worn out, but ankles are OK), so we don't yet know how to halt or reverse that deterioration. That's the role of ongoing research.
Joint replacement and fusion are reliable solutions when arthritis is painful and limiting despite extensive non-surgical treatment. Surgery like this is not done to restore normal, brand-new joints; it is designed to improve a patient's current function. Sure, all surgery has drawbacks, but no one should have surgery unless what is to be gained far outweighs the drawbacks.
When arthritic joints are overloaded with heavy physical work or vigorous sports, they're gonna hurt. Respect the biomechanics at stake, and you'll stay functional and comfortable. Listen to your joints, and do what they will allow. If you ignore them and expect more than they're capable of doing, they'll complain.
There's a broad range of treatments to relieve the symptoms of OA; your doctor should help you tailor a combination of those treatments over time as your symptoms wax and wane: activity modification (not overloading the joints), medication, exercise (to improve the tissues capable of improvement: muscle strength, ligament flexibility, balance, bone density), surgery (to improve a single joint's pain/instability--not restore the one God gave you.)
Magic wands do exist in medicine: antibiotics cure infection, insulin restores blood sugar to normal, pins and screws hold broken bones in place so they can heal properly. It's very likely the future holds a solution for cartilage deterioration--we just don't have it yet.
The Arthritis Foundation is an excellent resource for the latest research, news about treatment options, patient advocacy and support. Please visit and support them with your membership and donations. Check out the US Bone and Joint Decade, for reassurance that lots of smart people are working hard on behalf of people dealing with musculoskeletal problems!
Our Fractured Health System By the Seat of Your Pants
Unfortunately, what this story describes is true: bewildered patients, whose heads are spinning with technical jargon and what-ifs; their doctors pressed for time, because the payors don't value the time spent sorting out the variables intelligently with them; unending escalation of health costs if the rationale behind the treatment is "What do you want?"
Evidence-based medicine will guide decisions in the future, but for now it's just you and the seat of your pants.
Just imagine if you had the luxury of unlimited face-to-face consultation with your doctor to guide your decision. What's it worth to you? What kind of assistance would it take to help you understand your diagnosis, the treatment options, how to weigh the options in your circumstances, and follow you through a successful treatment? How would you organize your thoughts? Have you been handed any brochures or literature that's actually been helpful? How do you receive this level of service from other trusted advisors (whether your lawyer or hairdresser?) How much do you pay them? What's the solution?
August 18, 2005 in Commentary | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)